Representation in media refers to the way people, groups, events, and issues are portrayed in various forms of media, including television, film, news, and social media. It plays a crucial role in shaping how audiences perceive the world and the people within it, often influencing public attitudes and societal norms.

​

Media representations can either challenge or reinforce stereotypes and dominant ideologies. For example, the portrayal of gender roles in media often reflects broader societal beliefs. Historically, women were frequently depicted in domestic roles, reinforcing the idea that their primary function was within the home. Over time, as societal views on gender have evolved, media representations have also changed, with more diverse and complex portrayals of women in various roles, from leaders to action heroes. However, issues of misrepresentation or underrepresentation persist, particularly concerning race, ethnicity, and sexual orientation.

​

Representation is not just about who is portrayed but also about how they are portrayed. This includes the language used, the settings chosen, and the perspectives highlighted. For instance, news media might portray certain social groups in a negative light, emphasizing crime or poverty, which can contribute to biased or prejudiced views among the audience. Conversely, positive representation can help break down stereotypes and promote understanding.

​

The concept of representation also extends to the idea of "symbolic annihilation," where certain groups are either completely absent or only shown in limited, stereotypical ways. This lack of representation can lead to a sense of invisibility for those groups, affecting their social and cultural identity.

​

In the digital age, the landscape of representation is shifting as more individuals and communities gain the ability to create and share their own media content. This democratization of media production allows for more diverse voices and perspectives to be heard, challenging traditional media narratives and offering alternative representations that can reshape societal norms.​

​

CHECK YOUR UNDERSTANDING

​

1. What is meant by "representation in media," and why is it important?

2. How can media representations influence public attitudes and societal norms?

3. In what ways have media portrayals of gender roles evolved over time?

4. Despite changes in gender representation, what issues of misrepresentation or underrepresentation still persist in media?

5. Why is it important to consider not only who is portrayed in media but also how they are portrayed?

6. How can the portrayal of certain social groups in news media contribute to biased or prejudiced views among the audience?

7. What is "symbolic annihilation," and how does it relate to media representation?

8. How might the lack of representation or the presence of limited, stereotypical portrayals affect the social and cultural identity of certain groups?

9. How has the digital age changed the landscape of representation in media?

10. In what ways can the democratization of media production through digital platforms challenge traditional media narratives?

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

 

 

 

 

 

 

Media texts that have been critiqued for reinforcing stereotypes:

​

1. Race:

• Movie: Green Book (2018)

  • Criticism: The film has been criticized for perpetuating the "white savior" narrative, where a white character's perspective and actions are central to the story of racial reconciliation, often sidelining the black character’s experiences and agency.

2. Sex:

• TV Show: Two and a Half Men (2003-2015)

  • Criticism: The show often reinforces sexist stereotypes, portraying women in a reductive manner as either sex objects or nagging figures, while glorifying the misogynistic behavior of the male characters.

3. Gender:

• Movie: Wonder Woman 1984 (2020)

  • Criticism: Despite being a film centered on a powerful female superhero, the movie has been criticized for reverting to traditional gender stereotypes, particularly in the way Diana's character development is tied to her romantic feelings and loss, rather than her own strength and agency.

4. Disability:

• Movie: The Upside (2017)

  • Criticism: This film has been critiqued for reinforcing stereotypes around disability, particularly the idea that disabled people are pitiable and need a non-disabled person to "save" or "fix" them, a trope often referred to as "inspiration porn."

5. Age:

• TV Show: The Kominsky Method (2018-2021)

  • Criticism: While often praised for its humor, the show has been criticized for perpetuating ageist stereotypes, portraying older characters as perpetually confused, out-of-touch, and obsessed with their declining health, rather than as multifaceted individuals.

6. Class:

• Movie: Joker (2019)

  • Criticism: The film has been critiqued for its portrayal of working-class individuals as inherently violent and mentally unstable, reinforcing negative stereotypes about poverty and mental illness without offering a nuanced exploration of the systemic issues involved.

​

7. National Identity:

• TV Show: Homeland (2011-2020)

  • Criticism: The series has faced criticism for its portrayal of Middle Eastern and South Asian characters, often reinforcing stereotypes of these groups as inherently violent, suspicious, or connected to terrorism, thus perpetuating harmful biases related to national identity and race.

​

USEFUL VOCABULARY FOR TALKING ABOUT MEDIA REPRESENTATION

​

• Cultural Stereotypes – Oversimplified and generalized representations of groups that reinforce societal prejudices.

• Dominant Ideologies – The beliefs and values that are most widely accepted and promoted within a society, often reflected in media.

• Symbolic Annihilation – The absence or trivialization of certain groups in media, leading to their perceived insignificance.

• Positive Representation – Portrayals that challenge stereotypes and promote a diverse and accurate view of different groups.

• Misrepresentation – Inaccurate or biased portrayals of groups or individuals in media, often reinforcing harmful stereotypes.

• Gender Roles – The portrayal of socially constructed roles, behaviors, and norms associated with masculinity and femininity.

• Ethnic Stereotyping – Simplified and often negative portrayals of ethnic groups that fail to reflect their diversity and complexity.

• Underrepresentation – The insufficient presence or visibility of certain groups in media, leading to a lack of diversity.

• Hegemonic Masculinity – The dominant form of masculinity portrayed in media, often associated with strength, dominance, and heterosexuality.

• Intersectionality – The consideration of multiple overlapping social identities (e.g., race, gender, class) in media representation.

• Media Bias – The tendency for media to favor certain perspectives or groups, leading to unbalanced or partial representations.

• Audience Reception – How different audiences interpret and react to media representations based on their own experiences and identities.

• Encoding/Decoding – The process by which media producers encode messages into media texts, and audiences decode these messages, potentially in different ways.

• Cultural Identity – How individuals or groups see themselves and are perceived in relation to the cultural representations in media.

• Objectification – The portrayal of people, particularly women, as objects rather than as fully realized individuals, reducing them to their physical appearance.

• Social Constructionism – The idea that media representations contribute to the construction of social realities and norms.

• Queer Representation – The portrayal of LGBTQ+ individuals and communities in media, and the impact of these portrayals on public perception.

• Tokenism – The inclusion of a member of a minority group in media to give the appearance of diversity without fully integrating their perspectives.

• Normalization – The process by which media representations make certain ideas or behaviors seem normal or acceptable within society.

• Alternative Media – Media outlets or platforms that challenge mainstream representations and offer alternative perspectives.

​

​​

​ Line of Duty on iPlayer

​

​

​

​​

​

​

​

​

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

​

DISCUSSION

​

1. How does DCI Tony Gates' character reflect traits associated with hegemonic masculinity?

2. In what ways does the narrative of Line of Duty challenge the traditional stereotype of male authority figures in law enforcement?

3. How is Jackie Laverty portrayed in the episode, and what gender stereotypes does her character reinforce?

4. What is the significance of the romantic relationship between Jackie Laverty and Tony Gates in terms of gender representation?

5. How are female characters generally represented in this episode of Line of Duty?

6. What does the underrepresentation of minority characters in the episode suggest about race and ethnicity in media?

7. How does the portrayal of minority characters in subservient roles contribute to symbolic annihilation?

8. In what ways does the episode critique class dynamics within the police force?

9. How are working-class individuals portrayed in the episode, and what stereotypes are reinforced?

10. How does the episode use representation to critique societal stereotypes and dominant ideologies?

​

 

STUDENT ANALYSIS

​

​​​​​​​​​​"In Season 1, Episode 1 of Line of Duty, the REPRESENTATION of characters, institutions, and social issues is a critical component of the show’s narrative, reflecting and challenging various societal STEREOTYPES and DOMINANT IDEOLOGIES. This episode introduces a complex portrayal of law enforcement, with particular attention to the ethical dilemmas and moral ambiguities faced by the police, offering a nuanced commentary on power, corruption, and institutional responsibility.

​

The episode’s portrayal of GENDER ROLES is especially noteworthy. Detective Chief Inspector (DCI) Tony Gates is depicted as a highly successful male officer, embodying traits associated with HEGEMONIC MASCULINITY—authority, control, and professional success. His character is positioned within the DOMINANT IDEOLOGY of law enforcement, where male figures are often seen as the embodiment of order and strength. However, the narrative subtly critiques this representation by exposing Gates' involvement in unethical practices, such as manipulating crime statistics to enhance his career. This portrayal complicates the traditional representation of male authority figures in media, suggesting that success in such roles may come at the cost of moral integrity.

​

In contrast, female characters in the episode, while present, are generally portrayed in secondary roles that align with traditional GENDER STEREOTYPES. For example, Jackie Laverty, Gates' mistress, is depicted in a way that reinforces certain GENDERED EXPECTATIONS. Her character is associated with emotional manipulation and moral ambiguity, often seen in media as a trope for women in positions of romantic entanglement with powerful men. This portrayal risks reinforcing CULTURAL STEREOTYPES of women as dependent on or subservient to male figures, rather than as independent agents. However, the complexity of Jackie’s character also challenges these STEREOTYPES, as her actions have significant implications for the narrative, suggesting that she too wields a form of power, albeit within a more constrained societal framework.

​

The REPRESENTATION of RACE and ETHNICITY in this episode also merits discussion. While the central characters are predominantly white, the episode includes minority characters in supporting roles. However, these portrayals tend to reinforce CULTURAL STEREOTYPES rather than challenge them. For instance, minority characters are often depicted in subservient or peripheral positions, such as members of the police force who do not hold the same level of authority or narrative significance as their white counterparts. This UNDERREPRESENTATION and the limited scope of these characters' roles could contribute to SYMBOLIC ANNIHILATION, where minority groups are either marginalized or rendered invisible in media portrayals, leading to a lack of diverse and accurate representations.

​

CLASS REPRESENTATION is another critical aspect of the episode. Gates’ manipulation of crime statistics can be seen as a reflection of class tensions within the police force, where success is often measured by numerical achievements rather than ethical behavior. The episode portrays WORKING-CLASS individuals, such as those involved in the botched counter-terrorism operation, as being more susceptible to the consequences of institutional failures. This depiction reflects a broader societal narrative in which working-class communities are often shown as victims of systemic issues, reinforcing STEREOTYPES of vulnerability and marginalization. However, the show also critiques this dynamic by highlighting the moral decay within the upper echelons of the police force, suggesting that corruption and unethical behavior are not confined to any one class.

​

The concept of MEDIA BIAS is subtly woven into the narrative through the portrayal of the police force and the media’s coverage of their activities. The episode suggests that the media’s REPRESENTATION of law enforcement is often skewed by those in power, such as DCI Gates, who manipulate public perception through selective disclosure of information. This manipulation reflects broader concerns about the role of media in shaping societal views and the potential for MEDIA BIAS to reinforce DOMINANT IDEOLOGIES.

​

Finally, the episode’s portrayal of AGE and AUTHORITY presents another layer of REPRESENTATION. Older, more experienced officers like Superintendent Ted Hastings are depicted as morally upright, contrasting with younger, more ambitious officers like Gates, whose ethical compromises are central to the plot. This age-based representation reinforces STEREOTYPES of older individuals as being more principled and resistant to corruption, while younger characters are portrayed as more susceptible to moral failings in their pursuit of success.

​

In conclusion, Line of Duty Season 1, Episode 1 offers a rich tapestry of REPRESENTATIONS that reflect and critique societal STEREOTYPES and DOMINANT IDEOLOGIES across gender, race, class, and age. Through its complex characters and narrative, the show challenges traditional media portrayals, encouraging viewers to question the ethical underpinnings of institutional power and the BIASES that shape media representation. The episode’s nuanced approach to these issues highlights the importance of considering both who is represented in media and how they are portrayed, offering a critical lens through which to examine the broader societal implications of media narratives.

​